Q10: Suppose the Earth is perfectly spherical. A string is wrapped tightly around the equator of the Earth. Another string, metre longer, is placed around the Earth so that it forms a larger circle, staying the same distance above the ground everywhere. How high above the ground is the second string?
Repeat this for: (i) the Moon, (ii) Jupiter, (iii) a volleyball.
Are you surprised by the three answers? Why or why not?
We have a cylinder with a base radius of cm and height cm. A square pyramid is fitted inside it. The square base of the pyramid lies on the base of the cylinder, its corners on the boundary of the cylinder. The apex of the pyramid lies on the top of the cylinder. Find the ratio of the volume of this pyramid to the volume of the cylinder.
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- This question consists of two independent parts:
- Part A: We need to find the height above the ground of a second string that is metre longer than the circumference of a spherical body (Earth, Moon, Jupiter, or a volleyball) and is placed uniformly around its equator.
- Part B: We need to find the ratio of the volume of a square pyramid inscribed in a cylinder to the volume of the cylinder itself.
- Concepts used:
- Circumference of a circle formula:
- Volume of a cylinder:
- Volume of a pyramid:
- Properties of a square inscribed in a circle (base of the cylinder).
(i)PART I
A string is wrapped around the equator of a sphere of radius . A second string, metre longer, forms a concentric circle. How high is the second string above the ground? Calculate for Earth, Moon, Jupiter, and a volleyball.Step 1 — SET UP THE EQUATION FOR THE RADII AND CIRCUMFERENCE
Let the radius of the spherical body be metres.
The circumference of the first string (wrapped tightly around the equator) is:
The second string is metre longer than the first string and forms a circle of radius . Its circumference is:
Step 2 — SOLVE FOR THE HEIGHT ABOVE THE GROUND
Dividing the equation by :
The height of the second string above the ground is the difference between the two radii, :
Substituting the value of :
Step 3 — ANALYZE THE RESULT FOR DIFFERENT CELESTIAL BODIES AND OBJECTS
Notice that the expression for the height does not depend on the radius of the sphere. Therefore, whether it is the Earth, the Moon, Jupiter, or a volleyball, the increase in radius (the height above the ground) is always exactly the same.
- Are you surprised? Yes, initially it is surprising because common intuition suggests that a metre longer string would barely be noticeable on a huge planet like Jupiter compared to a small volleyball. However, mathematically, the radius depends linearly on the circumference (divided by ), so adding a fixed length to the circumference adds a fixed constant length to the radius regardless of the original size.
ANSWER (I)
The height of the second string above the ground is for all spheres (Earth, Moon, Jupiter, volleyball).
(ii)PART II
Find the ratio of the volume of a square pyramid fitted inside a cylinder to the volume of the cylinder.Step 1 — DEFINE THE DIMENSIONS OF THE CYLINDER AND THE PYRAMID
Let the radius of the base of the cylinder be and the height of the cylinder be .
-
Cylinder Volume:
-
Pyramid Dimensions:
The square pyramid has its base lying on the base of the cylinder and its corners on the boundary of the cylinder. Its apex lies on the top of the cylinder.- The height of the pyramid is equal to the height of the cylinder, i.e., .
Step 2 — FIND THE BASE AREA OF THE SQUARE PYRAMID
The corners of the square base of the pyramid lie on the circular boundary of the cylinder's base. Thus, the diagonal of the square base is equal to the diameter of the circular base of the cylinder.
Let the side length of the square base be .
The diagonal of the square is . Since it equals the diameter ():
Now, calculate the area of the square base:
Step 3 — CALCULATE THE VOLUME OF THE SQUARE PYRAMID AND THE RATIO
Using the formula for the volume of a pyramid:
Now, find the ratio of the volume of the pyramid to the volume of the cylinder:
Canceling from the numerator and denominator:
ANSWER (II)
The ratio of the volume of the pyramid to the volume of the cylinder is (or ).
COMMON MISTAKES
- Dividing Circumference Incorrectly: Students sometimes mistakenly try to divide the extra metre length directly by the radius instead of dividing the circumference formula by .
- Confusing Square Diagonal with Side: When finding the base area of the inscribed square pyramid, students often mistake the diameter of the cylinder for the side of the square rather than the diagonal of the square.