NEWAll India NCERT Mock Test Series is now live!Take Free Test
| Exercise end-of-chapter

Q6: A person is choosing between two mobile plans. Plan A: ₹50\text{₹}50 monthly fee + ₹0.20\text{₹}0.20 per minute of call time. Plan B: ₹30\text{₹}30 monthly fee + ₹0.30\text{₹}0.30 per minute of call time. Let xx denote the number of minutes of calling per month. (i) For how many minutes is Plan A cheaper than Plan B? (ii) For how many minutes is Plan B cheaper than Plan A? (iii) Find the number of minutes at which both plans cost the same. (Use the cost functions CA=50+0.20xC_A = 50 + 0.20x and CB=30+0.30xC_B = 30 + 0.30x.)

UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION

The problem compares two linear cost functions for mobile plans. Using the given expressions CA=50+0.20xC_A = 50 + 0.20x and CB=30+0.30xC_B = 30 + 0.30x, we must solve simple linear inequalities to find the range of minutes xx for which one plan is cheaper than the other, and solve a linear equation to find the exact minute when the costs are equal. All steps use basic algebra taught in NCERT Class 9.

(i)PART I

For how many minutes is Plan A cheaper than Plan B?

Step 1 — WRITE THE INEQUALITY FOR PLAN A CHEAPER

Plan A is cheaper when its cost is less than the cost of Plan B:
50+0.20x  <  30+0.30x50 + 0.20x \;<\; 30 + 0.30x

Step 2 — COLLECT LIKE TERMS

Subtract 3030 from both sides and subtract 0.20x0.20x from both sides:
20  <  0.10x20 \;<\; 0.10x

Step 3 — ISOLATE xx

Divide both sides by 0.100.10 (a positive number, so the inequality sign does not change):
200.10  <  x⇒200  <  x\dfrac{20}{0.10} \;<\; x \quad\Rightarrow\quad 200 \;<\; x

ANSWER (I)

x>200 minutesx > 200\ \text{minutes}

(ii)PART II

For how many minutes is Plan B cheaper than Plan A?

Step 1 — WRITE THE INEQUALITY FOR PLAN B CHEAPER

Plan B is cheaper when its cost is less than the cost of Plan A:
30+0.30x  <  50+0.20x30 + 0.30x \;<\; 50 + 0.20x

Step 2 — COLLECT LIKE TERMS

Subtract 5050 from both sides and subtract 0.30x0.30x from both sides:
−20  <  −0.10x-20 \;<\; -0.10x

Step 3 — ISOLATE xx (FLIP INEQUALITY)

Multiply both sides by −1-1 (changing the direction of the inequality) and then divide by 0.100.10:
20  >  0.10x⇒x  <  200.10  =  20020 \;>\; 0.10x \quad\Rightarrow\quad x \;<\; \dfrac{20}{0.10} \;=\; 200

ANSWER (II)

x<200 minutesx < 200\ \text{minutes}

(iii)PART III

Find the number of minutes at which both plans cost the same.

Step 1 — SET THE TWO COST EXPRESSIONS EQUAL

50+0.20x  =  30+0.30x50 + 0.20x \;=\; 30 + 0.30x

Step 2 — COLLECT LIKE TERMS

Subtract 3030 from both sides and subtract 0.20x0.20x from both sides:
20  =  0.10x20 \;=\; 0.10x

Step 3 — SOLVE FOR xx

Divide both sides by 0.100.10:
x  =  200.10  =  200x \;=\; \dfrac{20}{0.10} \;=\; 200

Step 4 — VERIFY THE COMMON COST (OPTIONAL)

Substituting x=200x = 200 in either expression gives:
CA=50+0.20×200=50+40=90 rupeesC_A = 50 + 0.20\times200 = 50 + 40 = 90\text{ rupees}
Thus both plans cost ₹90 when x=200x = 200 minutes.

ANSWER (III)

x=200 minutesx = 200\ \text{minutes} (both plans cost ₹90)

COMMON MISTAKES

  • Forgetting to reverse the inequality sign when multiplying or dividing by a negative number (as in part (ii)).
  • Treating the inequality 20<0.10x20 < 0.10x as 20=0.10x20 = 0.10x and solving for equality instead of the required range.
  • Ignoring the units; the answer must be expressed in minutes.

Was this solution helpful?