Q6: A person is choosing between two mobile plans. Plan A: monthly fee + per minute of call time. Plan B: monthly fee + per minute of call time. Let denote the number of minutes of calling per month. (i) For how many minutes is Plan A cheaper than Plan B? (ii) For how many minutes is Plan B cheaper than Plan A? (iii) Find the number of minutes at which both plans cost the same. (Use the cost functions and .)
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
The problem compares two linear cost functions for mobile plans. Using the given expressions and , we must solve simple linear inequalities to find the range of minutes for which one plan is cheaper than the other, and solve a linear equation to find the exact minute when the costs are equal. All steps use basic algebra taught in NCERT Class 9.
(i)PART I
For how many minutes is Plan A cheaper than Plan B?Step 1 — WRITE THE INEQUALITY FOR PLAN A CHEAPER
Plan A is cheaper when its cost is less than the cost of Plan B:
Step 2 — COLLECT LIKE TERMS
Subtract from both sides and subtract from both sides:
Step 3 — ISOLATE
Divide both sides by (a positive number, so the inequality sign does not change):
ANSWER (I)
(ii)PART II
For how many minutes is Plan B cheaper than Plan A?Step 1 — WRITE THE INEQUALITY FOR PLAN B CHEAPER
Plan B is cheaper when its cost is less than the cost of Plan A:
Step 2 — COLLECT LIKE TERMS
Subtract from both sides and subtract from both sides:
Step 3 — ISOLATE (FLIP INEQUALITY)
Multiply both sides by (changing the direction of the inequality) and then divide by :
ANSWER (II)
(iii)PART III
Find the number of minutes at which both plans cost the same.Step 1 — SET THE TWO COST EXPRESSIONS EQUAL
Step 2 — COLLECT LIKE TERMS
Subtract from both sides and subtract from both sides:
Step 3 — SOLVE FOR
Divide both sides by :
Step 4 — VERIFY THE COMMON COST (OPTIONAL)
Substituting in either expression gives:
Thus both plans cost ₹90 when minutes.
ANSWER (III)
(both plans cost ₹90)
COMMON MISTAKES
- Forgetting to reverse the inequality sign when multiplying or dividing by a negative number (as in part (ii)).
- Treating the inequality as and solving for equality instead of the required range.
- Ignoring the units; the answer must be expressed in minutes.