Q12: (i) Suppose is a parallelogram and are the mid‑points of and respectively. Show that the segments and trisect the diagonal . (ii) Using part (i), give a procedure to trisect any given segment . Then find two other methods to trisect : one that uses Exercise 11 above, and a third that employs the Centroid Theorem.
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- Part (i): We need to prove that the line segments and trisect the diagonal of a parallelogram , where and are the midpoints of sides and respectively. We use the Mid-Point Theorem and its converse, along with properties of parallelograms from Class 9 NCERT Chapter 8 (Quadrilaterals).
- Part (ii): We need to provide three different methods to trisect any given line segment :
- Using the result from part (i) via a parallelogram.
- Using the Mid-Point Theorem / intercept theorem concepts (referred to as Exercise 11).
- Employing the properties of the Centroid of a triangle (median concurrency point dividing each median in the ratio ).
(i)PART I
Suppose is a parallelogram and are the mid-points of and respectively. Show that the segments and trisect the diagonal .Step 1 — STATE GIVEN AND TO PROVE
Given: is a parallelogram. is the mid-point of side and is the mid-point of side . is a diagonal, and line segments and intersect at points and respectively.
To Prove: , i.e., and trisect the diagonal .
Step 2 — ESTABLISH QUADRILATERAL AS A PARALLELOGRAM
Since is a parallelogram, we have:
Since and are the mid-points of and respectively:
Thus, .
Also, since , the parts of these parallel lines are also parallel:
Since one pair of opposite sides ( and ) of quadrilateral is equal and parallel, is a parallelogram.
Similarly, quadrilateral is also a parallelogram because and ().
Step 3 — APPLY INTERCEPT / MID-POINT CONCEPTS IN TRIANGLE
Consider .
Since is the mid-point of , and is a parallelogram, we know . Thus, the line segment parallel to is not directly here, but consider :
In , is the mid-point of (so ). Since is a parallelogram, .
Consider or look at :
Let intersect at and intersect at .
In , is the mid-point of and (since ).
By the converse of the Mid-Point Theorem (or by applying the intercept theorem), is the mid-point of . Therefore:
Similarly, in , is the mid-point of and .
By the converse of the Mid-Point Theorem, is the mid-point of . Therefore:
Combining both results:
ANSWER (I)
The diagonal is divided into three equal segments , , and , thus showing that and trisect .
(ii)PART II
Using part (i), give a procedure to trisect any given segment . Then find two other methods to trisect : one that uses Exercise 11 above, and a third that employs the Centroid Theorem.Step 1 — METHOD 1: TRISECTING A SEGMENT USING PART (I) (PARALLELOGRAM METHOD)
Procedure:
- Let the given segment be (rename it to for convenience of construction).
- Construct a parallelogram on as one of its sides by drawing rays making an acute angle at and , cutting off equal lengths, or by constructing parallel lines.
- Locate the mid-point of and the mid-point of the opposite side .
- Join and to intersect the diagonal at two points, say and .
- By the proof in part (i), these points and trisect the diagonal . By scaling or similar geometric projection, the same ratio can be transferred to segment ().
Step 2 — METHOD 2: TRISECTING USING INTERCEPT / MID-POINT THEOREM (EXERCISE 11 CONCEPT)
Procedure:
- Let the given line segment be .
- Draw a ray making an acute angle with .
- Along the ray , mark three equal intervals using a compass: .
- Join the last point to .
- Through points and , draw line segments parallel to intersecting at points and .
- By the Intercept Theorem (or corollary of the Mid-Point Theorem regarding equally spaced parallels intercepting equal segments on any transversal), the points and divide the segment into three equal parts: .
Step 3 — METHOD 3: TRISECTING USING THE CENTROID THEOREM
Procedure:
- Let the given segment be .
- Construct an equilateral triangle or any triangle such that one of its sides is .
- Draw the medians of the triangle intersecting at the centroid .
- The centroid divides each median in the ratio from the vertex to the mid-point of the opposite side.
- By utilizing proportional division constructions based on the centroid property, one can divide a given segment into parts of ratio and , thereby achieving trisection of the segment.
ANSWER (II)
Three valid methods to trisect a segment are: (1) Using parallelogram diagonals and mid-points as proven in part (i), (2) Using parallel lines intercepting equal segments on a transversal (Intercept Theorem), and (3) Using the Centroid property of triangles dividing a median in the ratio .
COMMON MISTAKES
- Confusing Mid-Points: Incorrectly assuming and divide into three parts without establishing that the smaller triangles formed have their corresponding sides parallel and bisected.
- Using Coordinate Geometry: Applying distance formulas or section formulas with coordinates , which violates the Class 9 synthetic geometry curriculum.