Q10: Consider four points , , , in the plane with no three collinear. Answer the following questions. Some answers may require you to consider different cases, depending on how the points are positioned in the plane. (i) How many different quadrilaterals do they form if the quadrilateral is allowed to be self‑intersecting or non‑convex? (ii) How many of these quadrilaterals are self‑intersecting? How many are convex?
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We are given four distinct points , , , in a plane such that no three points are collinear.
- A quadrilateral is formed by joining four points in some order with line segments.
- We need to determine the total number of distinct quadrilaterals (including convex, concave, and self-intersecting) that can be formed by these four points, and then classify them into self-intersecting and convex quadrilaterals.
(i)PART I
How many different quadrilaterals do they form if the quadrilateral is allowed to be self‑intersecting or non‑convex?Step 1 — UNDERSTAND THE FORMATION OF A POLYGON FROM VERTICES
A quadrilateral is a closed figure bounded by four line segments connecting four vertices. To form a quadrilateral, we must choose an order in which to connect the four points , , , and cyclically.
Step 2 — DETERMINE THE NUMBER OF CYCLIC ARRANGEMENTS
Let us fix one point, say , as the starting point of the cyclic sequence. The remaining 3 points (, , ) can be arranged in a circle in distinct cyclic orders.
Since a quadrilateral traced in the forward direction is the same as one traced in the reverse direction (e.g., is the same geometric figure as ), we divide the total cyclic arrangements by .
ANSWER (I)
(ii)PART II
How many of these quadrilaterals are self‑intersecting? How many are convex?Step 1 — ANALYZE THE POSSIBLE CONFIGURATIONS OF 4 NON-COLLINEAR POINTS
Four non-collinear points in a plane can form either:
- A convex quadrilateral (where all 4 points form the vertices of a convex polygon, meaning all interior angles are strictly less than and all diagonals lie inside the figure).
- A triangle with one point inside it (which forms a non-convex or concave quadrilateral).
- A self-intersecting quadrilateral (where the sides cross each other, often called a bowtie or crossed quadrilateral).
Step 2 — CLASSIFY THE 3 POSSIBLE QUADRILATERALS
Out of the 3 possible quadrilaterals formed by joining the 4 points in all valid closed loops:
- Exactly 1 is a convex quadrilateral (or non-convex depending on whether the points form a convex hull or a triangle with an interior point. By standard combinatorial geometry for 4 points in general position, 1 is convex/concave and 2 are self-intersecting, or vice versa depending on the hull).
- Specifically, if the 4 points form the vertices of a convex quadrilateral, there is 1 convex quadrilateral and 2 self-intersecting quadrilaterals (formed by crossing the diagonals).
- If 3 points form a triangle and the 4th is inside, there is 1 non-convex quadrilateral and 2 self-intersecting quadrilaterals.
In standard combinatorial enumeration where all 3 topologies (cyclic orderings) are considered:
- Number of convex quadrilaterals = 1
- Number of self-intersecting quadrilaterals = 2
ANSWER (II)
COMMON MISTAKES
- Permutations vs. Combinations: Confusing the number of ways to choose 4 points (which is ) with the number of ways to order them into a polygon.
- Ignoring Self-Intersecting Figures: Forgetting that the question explicitly allows self-intersecting (crossed) polygons.