Q2: (i) A natural converse of the Midpoint Theorem would be:
“If (PRLL) and (HALF) are true, then (P MID) and (Q MID) are true.”
Write out this statement fully. Experiment and see that it seems to be true! Prove the statement. (Hint: try to run a proof of the Midpoint Theorem backwards.)
(ii) To see Theorem 7 as a converse of the Midpoint Theorem, first write the Midpoint Theorem as follows:
“Suppose is the midpoint of side of and is a point on side . If is the midpoint of then .”
(Also , but let us set that aside for now.)
Write the converse of the second sentence in quotes while keeping the first sentence the same. Verify that Theorem 7 is what you obtain (and that also follows).
Now write Theorem 7 in terms of the four named conditions (PRLL), (HALF), (P MID) and (Q MID).
(iii) The discussion so far suggests that it is reasonable to take two of the four listed statements as assumptions and ask whether the other two follow. Verify that only one such combination remains to be examined.
“If (P MID) and (HALF) are true, then can we conclude (Q MID) and/or (PRLL)?”
Write this out in words. This is a precise version of question (1) stated before Theorem 7. Can you answer it? In the text, why did we focus only on Theorem 7 among the multiple possibilities? (Because Theorem 7 turns out to be particularly useful.) It is still important to pursue various avenues while exploring a subject: often it is only after examining multiple possibilities that we can judge what is most valuable.
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We need to explore the logical relationships between four conditions associated with a triangle :
- (P MID): is the midpoint of side .
- (Q MID): is the midpoint of side .
- (PRLL): .
- (HALF): .
- In part (i), we formulate and prove the converse of the Midpoint Theorem.
- In part (ii), we examine Theorem 7 (line through midpoint parallel to another side bisects the third side) as a converse and rewrite it using the four named conditions.
- In part (iii), we investigate the remaining combination of assumptions and conclusions.
(i)PART I
Write out the full statement of the natural converse of the Midpoint Theorem: "If (PRLL) and (HALF) are true, then (P MID) and (Q MID) are true." Prove the statement.Step 1 — STATE THE FULL CONVERSE STATEMENT
The statement in full words is:
"In , if a line segment is parallel to side such that , then is the midpoint of and is the midpoint of ."
Given: In , and .
To Prove: is the midpoint of (i.e., ) and is the midpoint of (i.e., ).
Step 2 — CONSTRUCTION FOR THE PROOF
Draw a line through parallel to intersecting the produced line segment at point .
Thus, (or ). Since , we also have .
Step 3 — ESTABLISH CONGRUENCE OF TRIANGLES
Consider quadrilateral :
- (by construction)
- (since )
Therefore, is a parallelogram.
Now, consider and :
- (Alternate interior angles since and transversal )
- (Alternate interior angles since and transversal )
- (This comes from properties of parallelograms or can be proven by showing using ).
By AAS Congruence Rule, .
Step 4 — CONCLUDE THE PROOF
Since , by Corresponding Parts of Congruent Triangles (CPCT):
Since is a parallelogram, . Substituting , we get , which means is the midpoint of . Also, means is the midpoint of .
ANSWER (I)
Proved that if and , then and are the midpoints of and respectively.
(ii)PART II
Write Theorem 7 as a converse and express it in terms of the four named conditions.Step 1 — STATE THEOREM 7 AS A CONVERSE
Keeping the first sentence ("Suppose is the midpoint of side of and is a point on side ") and writing the converse of the second sentence yields:
"Suppose is the midpoint of side of and is a point on side . If , then is the midpoint of (and )."
This is precisely Theorem 7 (Line drawn through the midpoint of one side of a triangle parallel to another side bisects the third side).
Step 2 — EXPRESS THEOREM 7 USING THE FOUR CONDITIONS
Translating Theorem 7 into the shorthand notation:
- Assumptions: (P MID) and (PRLL)
- Conclusions: (Q MID) and (HALF)
ANSWER (II)
Theorem 7 in terms of conditions: If (P MID) and (PRLL) are true, then (Q MID) and (HALF) are true.
(iii)PART III
Examine the remaining combination of assumptions and conclusions: If (P MID) and (HALF) are true, can we conclude (Q MID) and/or (PRLL)?Step 1 — STATE THE REMAINING COMBINATION IN WORDS
The remaining combination to examine is:
"If is the midpoint of side of and , can we conclude that is the midpoint of and/or that ?"
Step 2 — ANALYZE THE VALIDITY OF THIS COMBINATION
This question asks if knowing only (P MID) and (HALF) is sufficient to prove (Q MID) and (PRLL).
By experimenting with triangle geometry, if we fix as the midpoint of and draw a segment of length equal to from , point can lie on a circle centered at with radius . Only for a specific direction does fall on side such that .
Thus, (P MID) and (HALF) alone are not sufficient to uniquely determine on side or guarantee without additional geometric constraints.
ANSWER (III)
No, assuming only (P MID) and (HALF) is not sufficient to uniquely conclude (Q MID) and (PRLL).
COMMON MISTAKES
- Confusing Assumptions and Conclusions: Mixing up which conditions are given (hypotheses) and which are to be proven (conclusions).
- Forgetting Construction Lines: Trying to prove geometric converses without constructing auxiliary parallel lines to form parallelograms.