Q16: A farm has some cows, sheep, and chickens. Last year the cows made up , the sheep , and the chickens . There was a decrease in the number of all three animals’ population over the year. Choose the possibilities for the change in their respective shares of the population:
(i) of cows decreased, of sheep decreased, of chickens decreased
(ii) of cows increased, of sheep increased, of chickens increased
(iii) of cows remained the same, of sheep remained the same, of chickens remained the same
(iv) of cows decreased, of sheep increased, of chickens remained the same
(v) of cows increased, of sheep increased, of chickens decreased
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We are given the initial percentage shares of three animals on a farm: cows (), sheep (), and chickens ().
- We are also told that the actual population of each of the three animals decreased over the year.
- We need to determine how the percentage share of each animal in the total population could change given that their individual counts decreased. In percentage problems, a decrease in the absolute number of a subgroup does not necessarily mean its percentage share decreased, because the total population also decreased. Conversely, shares must sum to , meaning it is possible for some shares to increase, decrease, or remain the same depending on the rates of decrease.
Step 1 — ANALYZE THE TOTAL POPULATION AND INDIVIDUAL DECREASES
Let the initial total population of animals on the farm be .
- Initial number of cows =
- Initial number of sheep =
- Initial number of chickens =
Over the year, the population of cows, sheep, and chickens all decreased. Let the new populations be , , and respectively, such that:
The new total population is , which is strictly less than the initial total population .
Step 2 — EXAMINE PERCENTAGE SHARES AND POSSIBILITIES
The new percentage share of an animal is its new population divided by the new total population .
Since all three absolute populations decreased, the new total is smaller. Depending on the exact rate of decrease for each animal:
- If all three decreased by the exact same percentage, their relative proportions remain unchanged (their percentage shares remain the same).
- If an animal's population decreased more than the overall total population decreased, its percentage share will decrease.
- If an animal's population decreased less than the overall total population decreased, its percentage share will actually increase, even though its absolute number decreased.
Therefore, mathematically, it is possible for the percentage shares of the individual groups to increase, decrease, or remain the same. Let us evaluate the given options based on whether their percentage shares can change in those directions while summing to .
Step 3 — TEST THE GIVEN OPTIONS
Let us check the consistency of the options:
- (i) of cows decreased, of sheep decreased, of chickens decreased: Possible, if all populations decreased at the same rate as the total population.
- (ii) of cows increased, of sheep increased, of chickens increased: Impossible, because all shares cannot increase when the total decreases (or shares must always sum to ).
- (iii) of cows remained the same, of sheep remained the same, of chickens remained the same: Possible, if all populations decreased by the exact same proportion.
- (iv) of cows decreased, of sheep increased, of chickens remained the same: Possible, if sheep decreased at a much slower rate than the total population, causing its relative share to rise.
- (v) of cows increased, of sheep increased, of chickens decreased: This requires two shares to increase and one to decrease. Since the sum of percentage shares must always equal , an increase in some shares can compensate for a decrease in others.
Thus, options (i), (iii), (iv), and (v) represent mathematically possible scenarios for percentage shares when individual absolute populations decrease.
ANSWER
The possibilities for the change in their respective shares are (i), (iii), (iv), and (v).
COMMON MISTAKES
- Confusing Absolute Count with Percentage Share: Assuming that if an animal's population decreases, its percentage share must also decrease. In reality, percentage is relative to the total population, which is also decreasing.