Q15: Given some data with corresponding weights, what would happen to the weighted average if all the weights are increased by a constant value, say ? If required, experiment with some data. What do you observe? Justify your answer using algebra.
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We are asked to investigate the effect on the weighted average (or weighted mean) of a given set of data when all the corresponding weights are increased by a constant value .
- The weighted average of a set of data points with respective weights is given by the formula:
- We need to use algebraic manipulation to observe and justify what happens when each weight is replaced by .
Step 1 — DEFINE THE ORIGINAL WEIGHTED AVERAGE
Let the given data values be and their corresponding initial weights be .
The original weighted average () is given by:
Step 2 — DEFINE THE NEW WEIGHTS AND NEW WEIGHTED AVERAGE
When each weight is increased by a constant value , the new weights become:
.
The new weighted average () is given by:
Step 3 — SIMPLIFY THE NUMERATOR ALGEBRAICALLY
Let us expand the numerator of :
Step 4 — SIMPLIFY THE DENOMINATOR ALGEBRAICALLY
Now, let us simplify the denominator of . Since there are data values, there are weights, and thus terms of are added:
Step 5 — EXPRESS THE NEW WEIGHTED AVERAGE AND CONCLUDE
Substituting the simplified numerator and denominator back into the expression for :
Observation: Unlike the unweighted arithmetic mean (where adding a constant to frequencies or weights under specific conditions might behave differently), the weighted average does not simply increase by a constant . Instead, the new weighted average depends on both the sum of the data values and the number of observations . It will only remain unchanged if the sum of the data points equals the original weighted average multiplied by , otherwise, it changes to a new value determined by the algebraic fraction above.
ANSWER
The weighted average becomes . It does not increase by a simple constant value; instead, the new average depends on the sum of the data values and the total number of observations .
COMMON MISTAKES
- Assuming a constant shift: Students often mistakenly assume that if all weights increase by , the weighted average will also increase by , similar to how adding a constant to each data observation shifts the mean by that constant.
- Algebraic expansion errors: Incorrectly distributing the data values into the terms .