Q13: Small-group project: Make a group of 3-4 students. Choose one scenario to design a custom rating scheme by assigning appropriate weights:
(a) shopping experience at a cloth store,
(b) travel experience in a bus,
(c) tourism experience of a nearby tourist spot,
(d) clinic/hospital experience
(i) Discuss and arrive at 4-6 aspects to rate. For each aspect chosen, justify why it matters for an overall experience.
(ii) Discuss and decide the relative weights and justify.
(iii) Collect or imagine ratings from at least 10 people on a scale of 1-5 (5 being very good).
(iv) Compute each individual rating. Compute the overall average across individuals.
(v) Make a 100% stacked bar chart using your data.
(vi) Write a short note on the observations and inferences, what your rating system captures well and what it misses.
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We need to design a custom weighted rating scheme for one of the given scenarios (let us choose (b) travel experience in a bus).
- Step (i): Identify 4-6 key aspects of the experience and justify their importance.
- Step (ii): Assign relative weights to these aspects and justify the weights.
- Step (iii): Simulate or collect ratings from 10 individuals on a scale of to for each aspect.
- Step (iv): Compute the weighted rating for each individual and the overall average rating across all individuals.
- Step (v): Describe how a stacked bar chart would represent this data conceptually.
- Step (vi): Write observations, inferences, strengths, and limitations of the rating system.
- Concepts used: Collection of data, arithmetic mean, weighted averages, and data interpretation from NCERT Class 9 Statistics.
(i)PART I
Discuss and arrive at 4-6 aspects to rate. For each aspect chosen, justify why it matters for an overall experience.Step 1 — SELECTION OF SCENARIO AND ASPECTS
We choose scenario (b) travel experience in a bus. For a bus journey, the following key aspects are chosen to rate:
- Punctuality (On-time departure and arrival): Matters because passengers plan their daily schedules and appointments around bus timings.
- Cleanliness and Hygiene: Matters because a clean environment directly affects the passenger's comfort and health during travel.
- Staff Behaviour and Politeness: Matters because courteous conductors and drivers make passengers feel safe and respected.
- Seat Comfort and Space: Matters because long hours of travel require adequate legroom and comfortable seating to avoid physical fatigue.
- Safety and Driving Speed: Matters because safe driving prevents accidents and instills confidence in passengers.
ANSWER (I)
Chosen 5 aspects: Punctuality, Cleanliness, Staff Behaviour, Seat Comfort, and Safety.
(ii)PART II
Discuss and decide the relative weights and justify.Step 1 — ASSIGNING WEIGHTS
Let the sum of all weights be equal to (or ). We assign the following relative weights based on priority:
- Safety and Driving Speed (): () - Safety is the most critical parameter in any transport service.
- Punctuality (): () - Timeliness is extremely important for regular commuters.
- Seat Comfort and Space (): () - Physical comfort greatly impacts journey quality.
- Staff Behaviour (): () - Good service interaction improves customer satisfaction.
- Cleanliness and Hygiene (): () - Important for hygiene, though secondary to safety and timing.
ANSWER (II)
Weights assigned: Safety = , Punctuality = , Comfort = , Staff Behaviour = , Cleanliness = (Total = ).
(iii)PART III
Collect or imagine ratings from at least 10 people on a scale of 1-5 (5 being very good).Step 1 — SIMULATED RATING DATA FOR 10 INDIVIDUALS
Let represent 10 passengers. Each rates the 5 aspects on a scale of to :
- : Safety=4, Punctuality=3, Comfort=4, Staff=5, Cleanliness=3
- : Safety=5, Punctuality=4, Comfort=3, Staff=4, Cleanliness=4
- : Safety=3, Punctuality=2, Comfort=3, Staff=3, Cleanliness=2
- : Safety=5, Punctuality=5, Comfort=4, Staff=5, Cleanliness=4
- : Safety=4, Punctuality=4, Comfort=5, Staff=4, Cleanliness=3
- : Safety=5, Punctuality=3, Comfort=3, Staff=3, Cleanliness=3
- : Safety=4, Punctuality=5, Comfort=4, Staff=4, Cleanliness=5
- : Safety=3, Punctuality=3, Comfort=2, Staff=3, Cleanliness=2
- : Safety=5, Punctuality=4, Comfort=4, Staff=5, Cleanliness=4
- : Safety=4, Punctuality=4, Comfort=3, Staff=4, Cleanliness=3
ANSWER (III)
Ratings from 10 individuals collected and tabulated for all 5 aspects.
(iv)PART IV
Compute each individual rating. Compute the overall average across individuals.Step 1 — FORMULA FOR WEIGHTED INDIVIDUAL RATING
The weighted rating for an individual is calculated as:
where are the ratings for Safety, Punctuality, Comfort, Staff, and Cleanliness respectively.
Step 2 — CALCULATING INDIVIDUAL WEIGHTED RATINGS
Using weights:
- :
- :
- :
- :
- :
- :
- :
- :
- :
- :
Step 3 — COMPUTING THE OVERALL AVERAGE ACROSS INDIVIDUALS
To find the overall average rating across all individuals, we sum the individual weighted ratings and divide by (using the arithmetic mean formula from Class 9 Statistics):
ANSWER (IV)
Individual ratings range from to . The overall average rating across all 10 individuals is .
(v)PART V
Make a 100% stacked bar chart using your data.Step 1 — CONCEPT OF 100% STACKED BAR CHART
In a stacked bar chart, each bar represents an aspect (or an individual) scaled to . The total height of each bar is uniform, and different segments within the bar show the proportional contribution of each rating category ( to stars).
- Construction Steps:
- Calculate the percentage distribution of ratings (1 to 5) for each of the 5 aspects across the 10 respondents.
- Draw horizontal or vertical bars of equal length ().
- Stack the percentage segments sequentially (e.g., proportion of 1-star, 2-star, 3-star, 4-star, and 5-star ratings) for each aspect using distinct shades or patterns.
ANSWER (V)
A conceptual description of constructing a stacked bar chart where each aspect's total responses are divided into percentage proportions of 1-to-5 star ratings.
(vi)PART VI
Write a short note on the observations and inferences, what your rating system captures well and what it misses.Step 1 — OBSERVATIONS, INFERENCES, STRENGTHS, AND LIMITATIONS
-
Observations & Inferences:
- The overall average rating of out of indicates a generally satisfactory bus travel experience.
- Safety and Punctuality received higher average ratings, showing reliable core service operations.
- Cleanliness received the lowest average rating, pointing to a specific area needing improvement.
-
What it captures well:
- It successfully quantifies subjective human experiences into a single comparable metric.
- Assigning weights ensures that critical factors (like safety) have a greater impact on the final score than secondary factors (like cleanliness).
-
What it misses:
- It fails to capture sudden unexpected events (e.g., sudden breakdown or rude behaviour by a specific ticket checker) which get averaged out.
- Numerical scales ( to ) lack qualitative context; a rating of '3' might mean different things to different passengers.
ANSWER (VI)
The rating system effectively highlights major operational strengths (safety, punctuality) and weaknesses (cleanliness), but misses nuanced qualitative feedback and individual contextual extremes.
COMMON MISTAKES
- Incorrect Weight Sum: Assigning weights whose total sum does not equal (or ), making the weighted average incorrect.
- Arithmetic Errors: Miscalculating the weighted sum for individuals or dividing by an incorrect total number of observations when finding the mean.