Q8: Observe the following infographic. What percentage of schools have a playground? (Map not to scale – How quantities combine: Understanding Data) (i) Identify the correct inference(s) from the statements given. (a) More schools have a playground in Haryana compared to Uttarakhand. (b) Approximately of the schools in Arunachal Pradesh have a playground. (c) Punjab has the highest number of schools with a playground. (d) Suppose it is given that Maharashtra has more schools than Telangana. Then the number of schools having a playground is more in Maharashtra. (ii) Using the information given, can we find the nation‑wide percentage of schools with a playground? If not, what additional information is needed?
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
The question asks us to interpret an infographic that gives, for several states, the percentage of schools that have a playground and the total number of schools in each state.
Part (i) requires us to decide which of the four statements follows logically from the data.
Part (ii) asks whether we can compute the overall national percentage of schools with playgrounds and, if not, what extra information is required.
The solution follows the Class‑9 NCERT method of working with percentages, weighted averages and comparison of numbers.
(i)PART I
Identify the correct inference(s) from the statements given.Step 1 — EXTRACT THE DATA FROM THE INFOGRAPHIC
For each state we note two numbers:
- Total number of schools, .
- Percentage of those schools that have a playground, .
These two pieces of information are required to find the actual number of schools with playgrounds in each state.
Step 2 — CONVERT THE PERCENTAGE TO A FRACTION
The fraction of schools with playgrounds in state is
Step 3 — COMPUTE THE NUMBER OF SCHOOLS WITH PLAYGROUNDS
The number of schools with playgrounds in state is
Step 4 — COMPARE THE NUMBERS FOR THE STATEMENTS
Using the computed values we can answer each statement:
(a) "More schools have a playground in Haryana compared to Uttarakhand" – true if
(b) "Approximately of the schools in Arunachal Pradesh have a playground" – true if
(c) "Punjab has the highest number of schools with a playground" – true if
(d) "Suppose it is given that Maharashtra has more schools than Telangana. Then the number of schools having a playground is more in Maharashtra" – true only if the higher total number of schools in Maharashtra outweighs any difference in the percentages. In other words, we need to check whether
Step 5 — STATE THE CORRECT INFERENCES
After performing the above calculations with the actual numbers from the infographic, the statements that satisfy the inequalities are the correct inferences. (In the given infographic, statements (a) and (b) are true, while (c) and (d) are false.)
ANSWER (I)
The correct inferences are (a) and (b).
(ii)PART II
Using the information given, can we find the nation‑wide percentage of schools with a playground? If not, what additional information is needed?Step 1 — UNDERSTAND THE WEIGHTED AVERAGE FORMULA
The national percentage of schools with playgrounds is a weighted average of the state percentages, weighted by the number of schools in each state. The formula is
Step 2 — IDENTIFY MISSING DATA
To apply the formula we need, for every state:
- The total number of schools, .
- The percentage of those schools that have playgrounds, .
The infographic gives for each state, but it does not give the total number of schools for all states. Without we cannot compute the weighted sum in the numerator or the total number of schools in the denominator.
Step 3 — CONCLUSION
Hence, with the information provided we cannot determine the nation‑wide percentage. We need the total number of schools in each state (or at least the total number of schools in the country) to compute the weighted average.