Q14: Find counterexamples to the following statements. (i) If is a prime number, then is a prime number. (ii) If is an even number, then is a prime number.
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We need to find counterexamples for two given mathematical statements involving prime numbers, even numbers, and algebraic expressions.
- A counterexample is an example that disproves a statement (i.e., shows that the statement is false for at least one case).
- Statement (i): If is a prime number, then is a prime number. To find a counterexample, we need to test prime values of until results in a composite number.
- Statement (ii): If is an even number, then is a prime number. To find a counterexample, we need to test even values of until results in a composite number.
(i)PART I
If is a prime number, then is a prime number.Step 1 — TEST SMALL PRIME NUMBERS FOR
Let us test some small prime numbers for in the expression :
-
For (prime):
-
For (prime):
-
For (prime):
-
For (prime):
Step 2 — CHECK IF THE RESULTING NUMBER IS PRIME OR COMPOSITE
Now let us check whether is a prime number or a composite number.
Since has factors other than and itself (specifically and ), it is a composite number, not a prime number.
Step 3 — STATE THE COUNTEREXAMPLE
For , is a prime number, but , which is a composite number. Thus, serves as a valid counterexample.
ANSWER (I)
is a counterexample, because is a prime number, but , which is a composite number.
(ii)PART II
If is an even number, then is a prime number.Step 1 — TEST SMALL EVEN NUMBERS FOR
Let us test some small even numbers for in the expression :
-
For (even):
-
For (even):
-
For (even):
Step 2 — CHECK IF THE RESULTING NUMBER IS PRIME OR COMPOSITE
Now let us check whether is a prime number or a composite number.
Since has factors other than and itself (specifically and ), it is a composite number, not a prime number.
Step 3 — STATE THE COUNTEREXAMPLE
For , is an even number, but , which is a composite number. Thus, serves as a valid counterexample.
ANSWER (II)
is a counterexample, because is an even number, but , which is a composite number.
COMMON MISTAKES
- Stopping too early: Testing only the first few values where the statement holds true (e.g., checking only for part (i) and concluding the statement is always true) without testing larger numbers.
- Misidentifying Prime Numbers: Incorrectly assuming large numbers like or are prime without checking their factors.