NEWAll India NCERT Mock Test Series is now live!Take Free Test
| Exercise 9.1

Q4: If x=yx = y, then a+x=a+ya + x = a + y, where xx, yy and aa are any three numbers. This proposition and its converse are routinely used while solving equations.

UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION

  • We need to analyze the proposition 'If x=yx = y, then a+x=a+ya + x = a + y' and its converse for any three numbers xx, yy, and aa.
  • This statement is directly related to Euclid's Axioms introduced in Class 9 NCERT Mathematics Chapter 5 (Introduction to Euclid's Geometry).
  • Specifically, it relates to the axioms concerning equality.

Step 1 — IDENTIFY THE RELEVANT EUCLID'S AXIOM

According to Euclid's Axioms in Class 9 NCERT Mathematics Chapter 5, Axiom 2 states:

'If equals are added to equals, the wholes are equal.'

In algebraic terms, if x=yx = y (equals) and a=aa = a (equals), adding aa to both sides gives a+x=a+ya + x = a + y, which means the wholes are equal. Thus, the given proposition is always true and is a direct application of Euclid's Axiom 2.

Step 2 — EXAMINE THE CONVERSE OF THE PROPOSITION

The converse of the proposition is:

'If a+x=a+ya + x = a + y, then x=yx = y.'

Let us verify this using Euclid's Axioms. According to Euclid's Axiom 3:

'If equals are subtracted from equals, the remainders are equal.'

Starting with the given equation:
a+x=a+y\begin{aligned} a + x &= a + y \end{aligned}

Subtracting the equal quantity aa from both sides (or using the cancellation law of addition):
(a+x)−a=(a+y)−ax=y\begin{aligned} (a + x) - a &= (a + y) - a \\[0.6em] x &= y \end{aligned}

Therefore, the converse is also true and is justified by Euclid's Axiom 3.

ANSWER

Both the given proposition and its converse are universally true for any real numbers xx, yy, and aa. The proposition is justified by Euclid's Axiom 2 ('If equals are added to equals, the wholes are equal'), and its converse is justified by Euclid's Axiom 3 ('If equals are subtracted from equals, the remainders are equal').

COMMON MISTAKES

  • Assuming algebraic rules are unproven: Students often use these properties mechanically without realizing they are founded on Euclid's fundamental axioms of geometry and arithmetic.
  • Confusing Axiom 2 and Axiom 3: Mixing up addition of equals (Axiom 2) with subtraction of equals (Axiom 3).

Was this solution helpful?

Quick Concept Check: Test Your Understanding

Interactive self-testing widget

?
Which Euclid's axiom justifies the statement 'If x=yx = y, then a+x=a+ya + x = a + y'?