Q2: Let us say that you have a box containing red pens, black pens and green pens. You pick a pen (without looking) from the box and put it back. Then your friend does the same. (i) What are the possible outcomes of the pen colours? Can you draw a tree diagram representing the possible outcomes? (ii) Can you use the tree diagram to guess the probability that both you and your friend pick pens of the same colour?
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We are given a box containing red pens, black pens, and green pens.
- Total number of pens in the box = .
- A pen is picked at random, and since it is put back (with replacement), the total number of pens remains the same () when the friend picks a pen.
- We need to determine the possible outcomes of the pen colours, represent them conceptually as a tree diagram, and then find the probability that both you and your friend pick pens of the same colour using basic probability concepts from Class 9 NCERT.
(i)PART I
What are the possible outcomes of the pen colours? Can you draw a tree diagram representing the possible outcomes?Step 1 — IDENTIFY THE GIVEN INFORMATION AND TOTAL PENS
Given:
- Number of red pens () =
- Number of black pens () =
- Number of green pens () =
- Total number of pens =
Since the first person replaces the pen before the second person draws, the total number of pens and the composition of the box remain unchanged for both draws.
Step 2 — DETERMINE THE POSSIBLE OUTCOMES FOR EACH DRAW
For each draw (by you and by your friend), there are three possible colour outcomes:
- Red ()
- Black ()
- Green ()
Since there are two independent draws (first by you, then by your friend with replacement), the total number of elementary outcomes in the sample space is possible pairs of colours.
Step 3 — DESCRIBE THE TREE DIAGRAM AND SAMPLE SPACE
A tree diagram starts with a first branch representing your choice:
- Branch 1: Red () with probability
- Branch 2: Black () with probability
- Branch 3: Green () with probability
From each of these branches, three sub-branches represent your friend's choice with the same respective probabilities (since the pen is put back):
- From : branches to , ,
- From : branches to , ,
- From : branches to , ,
Thus, the complete sample space consists of ordered pairs representing the colours of the pens chosen:
ANSWER (I)
The possible outcomes of the pen colours are represented by pairs: , where stands for red, for black, and for green.
(ii)PART II
Can you use the tree diagram to guess the probability that both you and your friend pick pens of the same colour?Step 1 — IDENTIFY FAVOURABLE OUTCOMES FOR SAME COLOUR
We need the probability that both you and your friend pick pens of the same colour. From our sample space of outcomes, these favourable pairs are:
- Both red:
- Both black:
- Both green:
So, the number of favourable outcomes is .
Step 2 — CALCULATE INDIVIDUAL PROBABILITIES USING TREE BRANCH PROBABILITIES
Alternatively, using the tree diagram probabilities for independent events with replacement:
- Probability of picking Red then Red:
- Probability of picking Black then Black:
- Probability of picking Green then Green:
Step 3 — SUM THE PROBABILITIES OF MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE EVENTS
Since these are mutually exclusive cases, we add their probabilities together:
(Note: If the question implies assuming all 9 colour outcome pairs are equally likely outcomes of colours rather than individual pens, then favourable outcomes = , total outcomes = , giving . However, accounting for exact pen counts via tree branch probabilities gives . Both interpretations are acceptable depending on whether the sample space is treated as uniform over colour pairs or weighted by individual pen probabilities.)
ANSWER (II)
The probability that both you and your friend pick pens of the same colour is (or if considering equally likely colour categories).
COMMON MISTAKES
- Ignoring Replacement: Forgetting that the pen is put back, which would incorrectly change the total number of pens to for the friend's draw.
- Confusing Outcomes with Events: Mixing up the number of individual pens with the number of colour categories when calculating probabilities.