Q15: (i) Rectangle has sides , and rectangle has sides . Show that has times the area of . Does this mean that copies of rectangle will fit into rectangle ? Check and see! (ii) has sides , and has sides . Show that has times the area of . Does this mean that copies of will fit into ? Check and see! (iii) has sides , and has sides . Show that has times the area of . Does this mean that copies of will fit into ? Check and see!
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We need to analyze the effect of scaling the linear dimensions of rectangles and triangles on their areas, strictly following Class 9 NCERT methods (such as the area formula for rectangles and Heron's formula for triangles).
- Part (i): For rectangle with sides and , and rectangle with sides and , we show the area is multiplied by and investigate whether copies can fit inside .
- Part (ii): For with sides and with sides , we use Heron's formula to show has times the area and check if copies fit.
- Part (iii): For with sides and with sides , we use Heron's formula to show has times the area and check if copies fit.
(i)PART I
Rectangle has sides , and rectangle has sides . Show that has times the area of . Does this mean that copies of rectangle will fit into rectangle ? Check and see!Step 1 — CALCULATE THE AREA OF RECTANGLE
Given:
- Length of rectangle
- Breadth of rectangle
Formula Used:
Step 2 — CALCULATE THE AREA OF RECTANGLE
Given:
- Length of rectangle
- Breadth of rectangle
Thus, rectangle has times the area of .
Step 3 — CHECK IF 4 COPIES OF RECTANGLE WILL FIT INTO
Since the dimensions of are and , we can mentally or physically divide rectangle into equal smaller rectangles, each having dimensions and .
Each of these smaller rectangles is congruent and identical in area to rectangle . Therefore, copies of rectangle will indeed fit perfectly into rectangle without any overlapping or leftover space.
ANSWER (I)
has times the area of , and yes, copies of rectangle will fit into rectangle .
(ii)PART II
has sides , and has sides . Show that has times the area of . Does this mean that copies of will fit into ? Check and see!Step 1 — CALCULATE THE AREA OF USING HERON'S FORMULA
Given:
- Sides of are .
Formula Used (Heron's Formula):
where semi-perimeter is:
So, . Let this be denoted as .
Step 2 — CALCULATE THE AREA OF
Given:
- Sides of are .
Let the semi-perimeter of be :
Now, applying Heron's Formula for :
Thus, has times the area of .
Step 3 — CHECK IF 4 COPIES OF WILL FIT INTO
By joining the midpoints of the sides of , the triangle is divided into smaller congruent triangles, each having side lengths equal to , , and .
Each of these smaller triangles is congruent to . Therefore, exactly copies of will fit into .
ANSWER (II)
has times the area of , and yes, copies of will fit into .
(iii)PART III
has sides , and has sides . Show that has times the area of . Does this mean that copies of will fit into ? Check and see!Step 1 — STATE THE AREA OF
Given:
- Sides of are .
- Semi-perimeter .
Step 2 — CALCULATE THE AREA OF
Given:
- Sides of are .
Let the semi-perimeter of be :
Now, applying Heron's Formula for :
Thus, has times the area of .
Step 3 — CHECK IF 9 COPIES OF WILL FIT INTO
Although the area is times larger, copies of cannot all fit into in the same orientation without overlapping, because a triangle cannot be subdivided into identical smaller triangles by simply dividing its sides into equal parts and connecting them in a grid-like fashion (unlike rectangles or scaling factors of ). Specifically, dividing each side into parts creates a tessellation pattern containing triangular regions, but only of them are oriented in the same direction as the original triangle while point in the opposite direction. Therefore, while the area ratio is , you cannot tile or fit identically oriented copies of inside .
ANSWER (III)
has times the area of , but identical copies of cannot all fit into due to directional orientation constraints.
COMMON MISTAKES
- Distributing Factors Incorrectly: Forgetting that when a factor like or is factored out of all four terms under a square root (like or ), it comes out of the square root as its square root value ( or ).
- Misinterpreting Area Scaling vs. Tiling/Fitting: Assuming that just because the area is times larger, copies of the exact same geometric shape can always be packed inside without regard to orientation and shape geometry (especially true for triangles where orientation matters).