NEWAll India NCERT Mock Test Series is now live!Take Free Test
| Exercise end-of-chapter

Q10: Two rectangles have the same area AA and the same perimeter PP. Does this mean that they are congruent to each other?

UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION

  • We need to determine whether two rectangles having the same area AA and the same perimeter PP must be congruent to each other.
  • Two figures are congruent if they have the same shape and same size (i.e., their corresponding dimensions, length and breadth, are equal).
  • We will analyze this using algebraic equations for the area and perimeter of a rectangle, taught in NCERT Class 9 curriculum.

Step 1 — DEFINE THE DIMENSIONS OF THE TWO RECTANGLES

Let the length and breadth of the first rectangle be l1l_1 and b1b_1 respectively.
Let the length and breadth of the second rectangle be l2l_2 and b2b_2 respectively.

Step 2 — SET UP EQUATIONS BASED ON GIVEN CONDITIONS

Given that both rectangles have the same area AA and the same perimeter PP:

  1. Perimeter equation:
    2(l1+b1)=Pand2(l2+b2)=P2(l_1 + b_1) = P \quad \text{and} \quad 2(l_2 + b_2) = P
    Therefore,
    l1+b1=P2andl2+b2=P2l_1 + b_1 = \dfrac{P}{2} \quad \text{and} \quad l_2 + b_2 = \dfrac{P}{2}

  2. Area equation:
    l1b1=Aandl2b2=Al_1 b_1 = A \quad \text{and} \quad l_2 b_2 = A

Step 3 — PROVIDE A COUNTEREXAMPLE TO TEST CONGRUENCE

Let us take a specific numerical example to test if the dimensions must be equal.

Let Rectangle 1 have length l1=4l_1 = 4 cm and breadth b1=1b_1 = 1 cm.

  • Area A=4×1=4 cm2A = 4 \times 1 = 4 \text{ cm}^2
  • Perimeter P=2(4+1)=10 cmP = 2(4 + 1) = 10 \text{ cm}

Now, let Rectangle 2 have length l2=2l_2 = 2 cm and breadth b2=2b_2 = 2 cm (which is a square, a special type of rectangle).

  • Area A=2×2=4 cm2A = 2 \times 2 = 4 \text{ cm}^2
  • Perimeter P=2(2+2)=10 cmP = 2(2 + 2) = 10 \text{ cm}

Both rectangles have the exact same area (4 cm24 \text{ cm}^2) and the exact same perimeter (10 cm10 \text{ cm}), but their dimensions are different ((4,1)(4, 1) versus (2,2)(2, 2)).

Step 4 — CONCLUSION

Since the dimensions (length and breadth) of the two rectangles are not necessarily equal, they do not have the same shape and size. Therefore, they are not necessarily congruent.

ANSWER

No, having the same area and perimeter does not mean that two rectangles are congruent to each other.

COMMON MISTAKES

  • Assuming Equal Area and Perimeter Implies Congruence: Students often confuse area and perimeter equivalence with geometric congruence. Congruence requires all corresponding sides to be equal.
  • Not Testing with Numbers: Failing to check with simple numerical values (like 4×14 \times 1 and 2×22 \times 2) which easily disprove the statement through a counterexample.

Was this solution helpful?

Quick Concept Check: Test Your Understanding

Interactive self-testing widget

?
Can two rectangles have the same area and perimeter without being congruent?