Q2: Let and be two points on a circle with centre . (i) Are there points on the circle, on the same side of , such that is different from ? (ii) Is it true that if , then and lie on the same side of the circle? (iii) If , and and do not lie on the circle, does the circle through and also pass through ?
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We need to analyze properties of angles subtended by a chord at points on a circle, based on Chapter 10 (Circles) of Class 9 NCERT.
- Core NCERT Concepts used:
- Angle in the same segment of a circle: Angles subtended by the same chord at any points on the circumference in the same segment are equal.
- Converse property: If a line segment joining two points subtends equal angles at two other points lying on the same side of the line segment, the four points lie on a circle (concyclic).
- Unique circle theorem: Through three non-collinear points, there passes one and only one circle.
(i)PART I
Are there points on the circle, on the same side of , such that is different from ?Step 1 — RECALL THE ANGLE IN THE SAME SEGMENT THEOREM
According to the NCERT Class 9 theorem (Angles in the same segment of a circle): "Angles subtended by the same chord at any two points on the circumference of a circle in the same segment are equal."
Step 2 — ANALYZE THE QUESTION STATEMENT
Since and are two points on the circle on the same side of chord , both and lie in the same segment of the circle subtended by chord .
Therefore, by the Angle in the Same Segment Theorem, we must have:
Step 3 — FORMULATE THE CONCLUSION
It is not possible for to be different from when both and lie on the circle on the same side of .
ANSWER (I)
No, because angles in the same segment of a circle are always equal.
(ii)PART II
Is it true that if , then and lie on the same side of the circle?Step 1 — ANALYZE THE GIVEN CONDITION
We are given that for two points and located on the same side of line segment .
Step 2 — CONSIDER CONCYCLIC POINTS AND THE CIRCLE PASSING THROUGH , AND
A unique circle can be drawn passing through the three non-collinear points , and . Let this be circle .
Step 3 — USE THE CONVERSE THEOREM
Since , the point subtends the same angle at chord as point does. By the converse of the angles in the same segment property, if a line segment joining two points subtends equal angles at two other points lying on the same side of the line segment, the four points are concyclic (i.e., they lie on the same circle).
Therefore, point must also lie on the same circle that passes through , and .
ANSWER (II)
Yes, and must lie on the same circle because of the converse of the angle in the same segment property.
(iii)PART III
If , and and do not lie on the circle, does the circle through and also pass through ?Step 1 — EXAMINE THE CONDITION WHERE AND DO NOT LIE ON THE CIRCLE
We are given that , but and do not lie on the same circle passing through and . This contradicts the fundamental geometric property that equal angles subtended by the same chord on the same side uniquely determine a unique circle passing through all four points ().
Step 2 — APPLY UNIQUENESS OF CIRCLES THROUGH THREE POINTS
A unique circle passes through any three non-collinear points. Consider the circle passing through , and . If and both and are on the same side of , point is forced by the angle equality to lie on the circumference of that exact same circle.
Step 3 — FORMULATE CONCLUSION
The premise that and do not lie on the circle contradicts while remaining on the same side of . Therefore, if , the circle through and must pass through .
ANSWER (III)
Yes, the circle passing through and must also pass through because the equality of angles forces to lie on the same unique circle determined by and .
COMMON MISTAKES
- Confusing sides of the chord: Assuming angles in alternate segments are equal instead of the same segment.
- Misinterpreting concyclic points: Forgetting that if a chord subtends equal angles at two points on the same side, those four points are necessarily concyclic.