NEWAll India NCERT Mock Test Series is now live!Take Free Test
| Exercise 5.5

Q3: In a circle, if the distance of chord ABAB from the centre is twice the distance of another chord CDCD from the centre, then can we conclude that CD=2ABCD = 2AB? Give reasons for your answer.

UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION

The problem asks whether a proportional relationship between the distances of two chords from the centre of a circle implies a proportional relationship between the lengths of the chords. We must use the Class 9 theorem that relates the length of a chord to its distance from the centre: chord length=2r2−d2\text{chord length}=2\sqrt{r^{2}-d^{2}}, where rr is the radius and dd is the perpendicular distance from the centre to the chord.

Step 1 — STATE THE GIVEN INFORMATION

Let OO be the centre of the circle and rr its radius.
Denote the perpendicular distances of chords ABAB and CDCD from OO by dABd_{AB} and dCDd_{CD} respectively.
According to the statement, dAB=2dCDd_{AB}=2d_{CD}.

Step 2 — RECALL THE CHORD‑LENGTH FORMULA (CLASS 9 THEOREM)

For any chord whose distance from the centre is dd, its length ll is given by
l=2r2−d2.\text{l}=2\sqrt{r^{2}-d^{2}}.
This follows from drawing the radius to the midpoint of the chord and applying the Pythagorean theorem.

Step 3 — EXPRESS THE LENGTHS OF ABAB AND CDCD

Using the formula:
AB=2r2−dAB2=2r2−(2dCD)2=2r2−4dCD2CD=2r2−dCD2.\begin{aligned} AB&=2\sqrt{r^{2}-d_{AB}^{2}} \\[0.6em] &=2\sqrt{r^{2}-(2d_{CD})^{2}} \\[0.6em] &=2\sqrt{r^{2}-4d_{CD}^{2}}\\[4pt] CD&=2\sqrt{r^{2}-d_{CD}^{2}}. \end{aligned}

Step 4 — CHECK WHETHER CD=2ABCD = 2AB HOLDS IN GENERAL

If CD=2ABCD = 2AB were always true, then
2r2−dCD2=2×2r2−4dCD22\sqrt{r^{2}-d_{CD}^{2}}=2\times 2\sqrt{r^{2}-4d_{CD}^{2}}
which simplifies to
r2−dCD2=2r2−4dCD2.\sqrt{r^{2}-d_{CD}^{2}}=2\sqrt{r^{2}-4d_{CD}^{2}}.
Squaring both sides gives
r2−dCD2=4(r2−4dCD2)r^{2}-d_{CD}^{2}=4\bigl(r^{2}-4d_{CD}^{2}\bigr)
⇒  r2−dCD2=4r2−16dCD2\Rightarrow\; r^{2}-d_{CD}^{2}=4r^{2}-16d_{CD}^{2}
⇒  3r2=15dCD2 ⇒  r2=5dCD2.\Rightarrow\; 3r^{2}=15d_{CD}^{2}\ \Rightarrow\; r^{2}=5d_{CD}^{2}.
Thus the equality CD=2ABCD = 2AB is true only when the radius satisfies r=5 dCDr=\sqrt{5}\,d_{CD}. This is a special condition, not a general rule.

Step 5 — PROVIDE A NUMERICAL COUNTER‑EXAMPLE

Take a circle of radius r=5 cmr=5\,\text{cm} and let dCD=1 cmd_{CD}=1\,\text{cm}.
Then dAB=2 cmd_{AB}=2\,\text{cm}.
Compute the chords:
AB=252−22=225−4=221≈9.17 cm,CD=252−12=225−1=224≈9.80 cm.\begin{aligned} AB&=2\sqrt{5^{2}-2^{2}}=2\sqrt{25-4}=2\sqrt{21}\approx9.17\,\text{cm}, \\[0.6em] CD&=2\sqrt{5^{2}-1^{2}}=2\sqrt{25-1}=2\sqrt{24}\approx9.80\,\text{cm}. \end{aligned}
Clearly CD≠2ABCD\neq2AB (in fact 2AB≈18.34 cm2AB\approx18.34\,\text{cm}).

Step 6 — CONCLUSION

The fact that the distance of chord ABAB from the centre is twice the distance of chord CDCD does not imply that CD=2ABCD = 2AB. The lengths of chords depend on the square‑root of r2−d2r^{2}-d^{2}, so a simple linear proportion between the distances does not translate into a linear proportion between the chord lengths, except in the special case where r2=5dCD2r^{2}=5d_{CD}^{2}.

ANSWER

No. In general CD≠2ABCD \neq 2AB. The chord lengths are given by AB=2r2−4d2AB=2\sqrt{r^{2}-4d^{2}} and CD=2r2−d2CD=2\sqrt{r^{2}-d^{2}} (where dd is the distance of CDCD from the centre). Equality CD=2ABCD=2AB would require the special condition r2=5d2r^{2}=5d^{2}, which need not hold.

COMMON MISTAKES

  • Assuming a linear relationship: Students often think that because the distances are in the ratio 2:1, the chord lengths must also be in the same ratio. The correct relation involves a square‑root, not a direct proportion.\
  • Forgetting to square the distances when applying the chord‑length formula, leading to algebraic errors.

Was this solution helpful?