NEWAll India NCERT Mock Test Series is now live!Take Free Test
| Exercise 5.1

Q1:
  1. AA, BB and CC are three collinear points. Can you find a point PP such that PA=PB=PCPA = PB = PC? What can you say about the perpendicular bisectors of ABAB and BCBC? Draw and check. Can you show that for three collinear points AA, BB and CC, the perpendicular bisector of ABAB and BCBC are parallel? Is it possible for a circle to pass through collinear points? Can you draw a line that cuts a given circle in three distinct points?
  2. The circumcircle of a given ΔABC\Delta ABC is drawn. Can there be other triangles congruent to ΔABC\Delta ABC that share the same circumcircle?

UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION

This question involves the concepts of Perpendicular Bisectors and Circles from NCERT Class 9 Mathematics, Chapter 10 (Circles) and Chapter 7 (Constructions/Geometry basics).

  • Part 1: We must determine if a single point can be equidistant from three collinear points. This requires understanding the locus of points equidistant from two points (the perpendicular bisector) and the properties of parallel lines.
  • Part 2: We must analyze if a circumcircle can contain other triangles congruent to the original one. This relies on the definition of a circumcircle and the properties of chords and arcs.

(1)PART 1

A, B and C are three collinear points. Can you find a point P such that PA = PB = PC? What can you say about the perpendicular bisectors of AB and BC? Draw and check. Can you show that for three collinear points A, B and C, the perpendicular bisector of AB and BC are parallel? Is it possible for a circle to pass through collinear points? Can you draw a line that cuts a given circle in three distinct points?

Step 1 — ANALYZE THE EXISTENCE OF POINT P

Let A,B,CA, B, C be three distinct collinear points.

Hypothesis: Assume there exists a point PP such that PA=PB=PCPA = PB = PC.

  1. Since PA=PBPA = PB, point PP must lie on the perpendicular bisector of the segment ABAB. Let this line be L1L_1.
  2. Since PB=PCPB = PC, point PP must lie on the perpendicular bisector of the segment BCBC. Let this line be L2L_2.

For PP to exist, L1L_1 and L2L_2 must intersect at a common point.

Geometric Property:

  • The perpendicular bisector of a segment is a line perpendicular to the segment at its midpoint.
  • Since A,B,CA, B, C are collinear, the segments ABAB and BCBC lie on the same straight line.
  • Therefore, the perpendicular bisector L1L_1 is perpendicular to the line ABCABC.
  • Similarly, the perpendicular bisector L2L_2 is perpendicular to the line ABCABC.

Conclusion on Parallelism:
Two distinct lines perpendicular to the same line are parallel to each other.
Thus, L1∥L2L_1 \parallel L_2.

Since L1L_1 and L2L_2 are parallel, they never intersect.
Therefore, there is no point PP that lies on both L1L_1 and L2L_2.

Answer: No, we cannot find a point PP such that PA=PB=PCPA = PB = PC for three distinct collinear points.

Step 2 — CIRCLE THROUGH COLLINEAR POINTS

Question: Is it possible for a circle to pass through collinear points?

Reasoning:
A circle is defined as the locus of points equidistant from a fixed point (the center).
If a circle passes through three distinct collinear points A,B,CA, B, C, then the center OO of the circle must be equidistant from A,B,A, B, and CC.
This implies OA=OB=OCOA = OB = OC.
As established in Step 1, the perpendicular bisectors of ABAB and BCBC are parallel and do not intersect. The center of a circle passing through AA and BB must lie on the perpendicular bisector of ABAB, and the center passing through BB and CC must lie on the perpendicular bisector of BCBC.
Since these bisectors do not meet, no such center OO exists.

Answer: No, a circle cannot pass through three distinct collinear points.

Step 3 — LINE CUTTING A CIRCLE IN THREE POINTS

Question: Can you draw a line that cuts a given circle in three distinct points?

Theorem: A straight line can intersect a circle at at most two points.

Proof/Explanation:
Let the equation of a circle be x2+y2=r2x^2 + y^2 = r^2 (conceptually, though we use geometric properties here).
Geometrically, a line is a straight path. A circle is a closed curve.

  • If the line is a secant, it intersects the circle at exactly 2 points.
  • If the line is a tangent, it intersects the circle at exactly 1 point.
  • If the line is external, it intersects the circle at 0 points.

It is geometrically impossible for a straight line to intersect a circle at 3 distinct points because that would imply the line curves or the circle is not a circle.

Answer: No, it is not possible to draw a line that cuts a given circle in three distinct points.

ANSWER (1)

  1. No, point PP does not exist. The perpendicular bisectors of ABAB and BCBC are parallel.
  2. No, a circle cannot pass through three distinct collinear points.
  3. No, a line cannot cut a circle in three distinct points.

(2)PART 2

The circumcircle of a given ΔABC\Delta ABC is drawn. Can there be other triangles congruent to ΔABC\Delta ABC that share the same circumcircle?

Step 1 — ANALYZE CONGRUENCE AND CIRCUMCIRCLE

Let ΔABC\Delta ABC be inscribed in a circle with center OO and radius RR.
The sides of the triangle are chords of the circle: AB,BC,CAAB, BC, CA.

Congruence Condition:
Two triangles are congruent if their corresponding sides are equal (SSS Congruence Rule).
So, we are looking for a triangle ΔA′B′C′\Delta A'B'C' inscribed in the same circle such that:
A′B′=ABA'B' = AB
B′C′=BCB'C' = BC
C′A′=CAC'A' = CA
Geometric Construction:

  1. Consider the chord ABAB. In a circle, a chord subtends a specific arc. There are two possible positions for the third vertex CC such that ACAC and BCBC maintain the same lengths relative to ABAB.

    • One position is the original point CC.
    • The other position is the reflection of CC across the line ABAB. Let's call this point C′C'.
  2. If we reflect ΔABC\Delta ABC across the side ABAB, we get ΔABC′\Delta ABC'.

    • ABAB is common.
    • AC′=ACAC' = AC (by reflection symmetry).
    • BC′=BCBC' = BC (by reflection symmetry).
    • Since CC lies on the circumcircle, its reflection C′C' across the chord ABAB also lies on the same circumcircle (because the circle is symmetric about any diameter, and specifically, the arc lengths are preserved).
  3. Thus, ΔABC′\Delta ABC' is congruent to ΔABC\Delta ABC (by SSS) and shares the same circumcircle.

Are there others?
Yes. We can reflect across any side. For example, reflecting across BCBC gives ΔA′BC\Delta A'BC, which is also congruent to ΔABC\Delta ABC and inscribed in the same circle.

Conclusion:
Yes, there can be other triangles congruent to ΔABC\Delta ABC that share the same circumcircle. Specifically, the reflections of ΔABC\Delta ABC across its sides (or any rotation/reflection that maps the vertices to other points on the circle maintaining side lengths) will form congruent triangles inscribed in the same circle.

ANSWER (2)

Yes, there can be other triangles congruent to ΔABC\Delta ABC that share the same circumcircle. For example, the reflection of ΔABC\Delta ABC across any of its sides will result in a congruent triangle inscribed in the same circle.

Was this solution helpful?