Q2: Look at the sequence of numbers on one column of the Ishango bone: . What do these numbers have in common? List the next three numbers that fit this pattern. We know that Natural Numbers are closed under addition (the sum of any two natural numbers is always a natural number). Are they closed under subtraction? Provide a couple of examples to justify your answer.
SOLUTION
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- Identify that are consecutive prime numbers.
- Test the closure property of natural numbers under subtraction by using a counterexample where the result is not a natural number.
(i)PART I
Look at the sequence of numbers on one column of the Ishango bone: . What do these numbers have in common? List the next three numbers that fit this pattern.Step 1 — IDENTIFY PATTERN AND NEXT NUMBERS
The given numbers share the common property that they are prime numbers. Continuing the sequence of prime numbers after 19, the next three primes are:
ANSWER (I)
They are prime numbers. The next three numbers are 23, 29, 31.
(ii)PART II
We know that Natural Numbers are closed under addition. Are they closed under subtraction? Provide a couple of examples to justify your answer.Step 1 — TEST SUBTRACTION CLOSURE
A set is closed under an operation if operating on any two elements of the set yields an element in the set. Consider natural numbers and :
Since is an integer but not a natural number, natural numbers are not closed under subtraction.
ANSWER (II)
No, natural numbers are not closed under subtraction (e.g., , which is not a natural number).
COMMON MISTAKES
- Confusing odd numbers with prime numbers: Assuming or comes next in the sequence because they are odd.
- Partial closure assumption: Assuming closure holds because (a natural number), forgetting that closure must hold for all pairs.